The Paragraph Four Report®
Frequently Asked Questions
Exactly what products are included in ParagraphFour.com?
Products include the universe of products that are currently under Paragraph IV Challenge (under 505(j) of the statute). We also include 505(b)(2) cases, DESI products, Biologics cases (filed after 2012 – the BPCIA cases), Inter Partes Reviews, and antibiotics drugs (though some are not technically filed under Paragraph IV.) Currently, there are over 800 products covered. The start date of the database is November 1, 2003 — so it includes every PIV case and product that was “active” on that date. By “active,” we mean the product had a PIV challenge, had a pending lawsuit, and was not available as a generic on November 1, 2003. We follow the case through completion (settlement, court of appeals, etc). Once a generic product enters the market after final termination of litigation in its favor (usually after appeal — or the litigation otherwise terminates), the product is removed from the list and sent to the “Old Cases” Section (so no product and its data/cases leaves the database.) The”Old Cases” Section includes products and cases closed after November 1, 2003.
How often is the information updated?
We check for new cases and products (and Court of Appeals opinions) 2-3 times per week. When adding new products and cases, the real time will depend on the court docket itself, and a new case can appear on the site as little as a day or two after a suit is filed but usually no later than every 1-2 weeks. As for updating the status of pending cases, it depends. If the Court is near a significant decision (such as after a Bench Trial or MSJ), then the docket is checked every other week; if the case is plodding along (discovery, for example), the docket is updated once a month. In addition, there is a Monthly Update of all activity.
In addition, note that we are not a newswire and do not have instant, up-to-the minute information on court decisions. There are technical reasons why we can’t. Typically, when a Court renders an important decision, often the parties and their attorneys will know before anyone else, and one (or both) of the companies involved will typically transmit a press release which a newswire service will pick up, making the information generally known. We are a research site, not a news bureau.
Are all of the court cases in ParagraphFour.com?
It is difficult to say with absolute certainty whether the research has captured every single case. Typically, if a case is missed, it is due to clerical error at the Clerk’s office. Occasionally, Clerks of the Court mis-categorize cases so they are not picked up in the search engines. Remember that these cases affect about 20 jurisdictions and span over fifteen years so there is a chance that a clerk out there has made an error. Sometimes, we may overlook a case as well. While we take effort to find these “missing” cases and have found about 10 such cases misfiled over the past fifteen years, there is a slight chance for error. As of December 2018, there are over 4,000 cases in the database, and we believe that they represent the universe of Paragraph IV cases. However, it would not surprise us if a case or two is floating out there that has not been captured.
What about situations where the brand does not sue the ANDA applicant?
About 15% of the time, a brand company will not file a suit against the generic. Typically, this occurs when the generic company has not certified against the molecule patent but has certified against others that the brand has chosen not to defend. For our purposes, after a product appears on the FDA PIV List, we wait about 3-4 months, and if we don’t see a suit on the product, we review the Orange Book to see if there is a logical reason why there is no suit. If there is, we will place it in the database and provide our opinion what the situation likely is and during monthly updating, see if tentative approvals have appeared. We state when we speculate. If the situation is not clear from the public data, we will not take a “wild guess” and will leave the product out of the database.
Do you offer downloads to all of the court documents and files?
No. As a courtesy to our subscribers, we have scanned the Complaints and/or Answers to each case. We also scan and included all court opinions and all Court of Appeals opinions. All of these documents are available for downloading at no additional cost. As of December 2018, we have over 11,500 document downloads. However, we are not a document retrieval service, and sometimes pleadings go missing from the clerk’s office or are sealed.
Does the site include Citizen Petitions or 'peripheral cases' such as those filed between generic companies over the 180-day exclusivity?
If a Citizen Petition has been filed on a PIV product after January 1, 2004, it is noted in the product topic and directs the subscriber to FDAPetitions.com. We make an attempt to find and include mention of “peripheral cases.” While we make attempts to direct the subscriber to all petitions and peripheral cases, these special notes may not be exhaustive.
Does the database include an in-depth analysis of the case itself and an opinion on which company might win the patent dispute?
No. While acknowledging that some case analysis can be helpful, but having actually tried cases in federal court, we firmly believe that cases are not something that can be accurately predicted. Moreover, the reality is that many court documents — the ones that would give a great deal of insight into a case — are typically “sealed” and not available for public view. We like to keep it to the facts and not speculate or evaluate on patent cases. We leave that up to our subscribers.
How is the data made available to subscribers?
ParagraphFour.com is available over the internet. Our goal is to have the site available every day, 24 hours a day. We have the site on a dedicated server, and the data is backed up daily. So, if there were ever a problem, an interruption of service might only be a few hours. Since launching in 2004, we have had about 20 hours of downtime, if that.
Can I get a free trial?
No. However, we demonstrate the site over the Internet. It takes about 20-30 minutes.
When I do a Search, I can't seem to find the product that I am looking for and that product is on the FDA List of Products with Paragraph IV Certifications. Where is it?
If the product you are searching for appears on the FDA List but you can’t find it here, there could be one of three reasons:
- Sometimes, a company won’t file a lawsuit for infringement so there is no reliable access to the information. We will wait for a PIV case to surface before adding it to the site. So, it might be a matter of time before it is added, or if no case is filed and we can’t verify through company or other reliable sources, we do not include it. We won’t speculate on data.
- FDA does not remove products from its list, so some of them have long gone generic (eg, FDA still lists fluoxetine though it has had generic competion since August 2001), and cases/products terminated before November 1, 2003 are not included (so products such as fluoxetine or omeprazole are not included).
- If the product’s case finally terminated after November 1, 2003, the product has been moved to the Old Cases section. For The Paragraph Four Report, we send products to the Old Cases section when there are generics available (after favorable judicial decision or the litigation otherwise terminates.)
I noticed that there are products in your Paragraph IV information that do not appear in the FDA List of those with Paragraph IV Certifications. Why?
Two reasons: (1) Through our research, we have found that the FDA List occasionally omits a product or product dosage. (If you don’t believe us, read the Complaints.) (2) We include antibiotic products that aren’t technically Paragraph IV cases so they don’t appear on the FDA List. A quick technical note on antibiotics — those with NDA’s filed after November 20, 1997 are subject to the Paragraph IV rules.
Why are some of the Patent Expiration dates omitted for a few products and their patents?
For Patent Expiration dates, we rely on the Orange Book. So, for patents not listed (antibiotics, process patents, for example), we do not make an independent judgment as to when they expire although we are certainly capable of figuring it out. After all, no one really knows when a company will claim the patent expires, so we leave it up to you.
How are amended pleadings researched and handled?
In general, while we review all dockets on a monthly basis, we do not review or collect amended pleadings. However, if the plaintiff files an amended complaint before the answer is filed, we will review it and include it as a download. On occasion, if there are a massive amounts of amended pleadings in a case, we will review these to see what, if anything, has changed from the case as initially filed.
Can you explain the litigation process and timing of court cases?
When cases are filed in the District Court, the companies (or “parties”) file Pleadings (Complaint and Answer) which briefly outline the legal dispute. After the parties file Pleadings, they conduct Discovery where they exchange documents and talk to each other’s witnesses. Technically, the Discovery phase should last about four months, but, because these cases are complex, it can last anywhere from 6-18 months.
After the parties have conducted Discovery and are preparing their cases, they enter the Pre-trial phase where the Judge and parties get together and outline what the case issues will be. Then, the actual Trial takes place. Pre-trial and the Trial itself can often take a few months. After the Trial ends, the Judge usually won’t make a decision right away; instead the Judge will conduct Post-trial proceedings to discuss and argue further points of law.
After Post-trial, the Judge then renders a Judgment. The Judge can take as long as he or she wants to, so the Final Judgment may take an additional 4-6 months. After the Judge renders its decision, the losing party will often file an Appeal which can take around 12-16 months to conclude.
The whole process from the Pleadings to a final decision can take 2-3 years, sometimes longer, not counting the appeal. The process will often outlast the 30-month stay provision. However, there are some procedures parties use to make it shorter, typically through a Summary Judgment where basically one party will say to the Judge, “Here are the facts we can all agree on, and given those facts and the law, we should win.” If a party wins a Summary Judgment, the case will end quickly, but, of course can be appealed.
How do I subscribe?
Check out the Get Access button for more information
The Paragraph Four Report, ParagraphFour.com, and the PFOUR logo are trademarks of Parry Ashford Inc.
©2019 Parry Ashford Inc.
Terms and Conditions -- Subscription Agreement
PARAGRAPHFOUR.COM SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT
Terms and Conditions
Please read the Terms and Conditions. By receiving a username and password, and by logging in as a “Member,” you certify that you have read and agree to abide by all such Terms and Conditions and that you are authorized to agree and abide by all such Terms and Conditions on behalf of your company or institution (hereafter referred to as “Subscriber”).
By this Agreement, Parry Ashford Inc. (“Parry Ashford Inc.”), 100 S. Ashley Drive, Suite 600, Tampa, FL 33602 USA grants a license to the Subscriber to access the subscriber-only sections of Paragraphfour.com on the Internet from the number of sites (as defined below) specified in Section 4 of this Agreement, subject to the terms and conditions set forth in the following paragraphs, all of which are hereby agreed to between Parry Ashford Inc. and the Subscriber.
Terms and Conditions
1. Paragraphfour.com. Paragraphfour.com is an online compilation of public records, information from public records, and original articles (collectively, “publications”). Parry Ashford Inc. reserves the right to add or delete Paragraphfour.com content at any time.
2. Scope of License; Institutional Subscriber Use Restrictions. The subscription includes authorization by means of the Subscriber’s IP address to allow site-wide online access by authorized users via multiple connections. If a proxy server is being registered for access, the Subscriber agrees to maintain the security of the access by authenticating authorized users before allowing use of the proxy to any remote or on-site user. Authorized users must be employees, staff, or (for academic Subscribers) faculty or students, officially affiliated with the Subscriber, or authorized on-site patrons of the Subscriber’s library facilities.
Sites may be academic or nonacademic. For academic Subscribers, different campuses are considered different sites even if they are within the same city. Departments or libraries of the same campus are considered part of the same site. For nonacademic Subscribers, sites are defined as geographically separate units, even if they are within the same city. Each branch, office, or laboratory is a different site.
This subscription entitles the Subscriber and authorized users to access all portions of Paragraphfour.com and:
a. make searches of Paragraphfour.com
b. download search results to paper, hard disk, or diskette, provided that such data is not made available to anyone who is not an authorized user. Authorized users who do download search results must maintain all copyright and other notices.
Systematic downloading of substantial portions of the database and use of robots is prohibited.
Academic and public library Subscribers may use hard copies derived from the electronic edition of the publications for the purpose of inter-library loan with the same limitations that apply to copies for that purpose made from the print or online versions of the publications. Specifically, copies must be made in compliance with Section 108 of the Copyright Act of the U.S. and be within the CONTU guidelines. Authorized users who do print items must maintain all copyright and other notices on the printed items.
A Subscriber or authorized user may not make Paragraphfour.com available to anyone other than another authorized user, whether by telephone link, Internet connection, or by permitting access through his or her terminal or computer, or by other similar or dissimilar means or arrangements.
Subscribers will make reasonable efforts to maintain security and monitor all use (including unauthorized use) from their sites and to communicate the terms of the license to their users.
3. Access. Paragraphfour.com access is granted site-wide only for those users specifically agreed upon in writing by Confirmation E-mail. Subscribers may request access for any number of users; however, usage must be restricted to a single site, or such larger number of sites as may be expressly stated in the subscription agreement.
4. Term and Fees. The annual subscription fee shall be as agreed upon in writing by Confirmation E-mail. The fee shall be payable within 30 (thirty) days after receipt of invoice. Subsequent annual subscription fees shall be invoiced by Parry Ashford Inc. and shall be due and payable within 30 (thirty) days of receipt.
Subscriber and its authorized users must use the assigned usernames and passwords in order access to the Subscriber-only portions of Paragraphfour.com.
The term and each renewal term of a subscription will last through one year after the term begins (the “Renewal Date”). The subscription will renew thereafter for successive one year terms unless Subscriber cancels the subscription by providing at least thirty (30) days written notice before the Renewal Date of such cancellation.
The annual fee for this subscription may be raised by written notice to the Subscriber, given at least sixty 60 days prior to the next succeeding Renewal Date. Subscriber may terminate a subscription, effective on the next Renewal Date, by at least 30 days written notice to Parry Ashford Inc., which may be given by e-mail through the Customer Service link on the Paragraphfour.com website. The Subscriber will be liable for the subscription fee for the upcoming renewal term if it fails to give notice of termination at least 30 days before the Renewal Date.
Payment in full for a renewal term is due within thirty (30) days after receipt of invoice which shall be sent to Subscriber on or before the Renewal Date. There is no grace period, and access to Paragraphfour.com will terminate after the Renewal Date until payment is made. Late payment of the full year’s subscription fee will reinstate the subscription through the end of the calendar year in which the payment is made.
5. Support. Paragraphfour.com includes online documentation. Parry Ashford Inc. does not provide user support via e-mail, telephone, or otherwise.
6. Copyright and Violations of Contract. Paragraphfour.com and its contents are subject to copyright, database protection, and other rights of the publisher (Parry Ashford Inc.), under the laws of the United States and the country of use.
The Subscriber acknowledges that it has no claim to ownership by reason of its use of or access to Paragraphfour.com. Downloading of data is permitted solely for Subscriber’s internal use to the same extent as the printed version of the publication. Recompiling, publication or republication of the data, or any portion thereof, in any form or medium whatsoever, may be done only with specific written permission from Parry Ashford Inc.
Resale of data downloaded from the database, whether such resale be in the form of sale, subscription, or otherwise, whether the format or appearance of the data be similar to or different from its appearance on Paragraphfour.com, and whether the data be in printed, electronic, or other form, is prohibited. Violators of any of the restrictions set forth in this paragraph shall be liable either for copyright infringement or, to the extent that the downloaded data are not protected by copyright laws, for damages for breach of contract and/or trespass in the amount of (a) actual damages or (b) liquidated damages calculated as if the data in question were protected by the copyright laws, whichever may be greater, together with Parry Ashford Inc.’ reasonable attorneys’ fees and other expenses in pursuing such remedies.
7. Suspension or termination of access. Parry Ashford Inc. reserves the right to suspend and/or terminate access to Paragraphfour.com without prior notice if Subscriber violates any term of this Agreement and shall not be liable to Subscriber for any portion or refund of the subscription fee. Any use of the Paragraphfour.com database beyond the scope of the License or any fraudulent, abusive, or otherwise illegal activities may be grounds for termination of access. The foregoing includes but is not limited to activity that may burden Parry Ashford Inc.’ server(s), such as computer programs that automatically download content, commonly known as robots, spiders, crawlers, wanderers or accelerators.
8. Disclaimer of warranties.
a. Parry Ashford Inc. has made and will make good faith efforts to ensure that Paragraphfour.com is complete and accurate. However, Parry Ashford Inc. does not warrant completeness or accuracy, and does not warrant that the Subscriber’s use of Paragraphfour.com will be uninterrupted or error-free, or that the results obtained will be useful or will satisfy the Subscriber’s requirements.
b. Parry Ashford Inc. warrants that it is entitled to grant the licenses outlined in this Agreement, BUT MAKES NO OTHER WARRANTIES OR REPRESENTATIONS OF ANY KIND, EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE, NONINFRINGEMENT, OR PREVENTION OF HACKING.
c. The Subscriber will be permitted to access Paragraphfour.com at any time while a subscription term is in effect. Parry Ashford Inc. will not be liable for any delay, down time, or other failure of performance, but will use reasonable efforts to correct any performance problem brought to its attention.
d. Parry Ashford Inc. will not be responsible for incidental, consequential, or any other damages arising out of or in connection with the service or materials provided hereunder.
e. The Subscriber assumes the sole responsibility for all use of Paragraphfour.com and agrees to indemnify and hold Parry Ashford Inc. harmless from any liability or claim of any person arising from such use.
a. The obligations of the Subscriber under this Agreement or under the law with respect to copyright and other protections of the publications or any other intellectual property that is part of or associated with Paragraphfour.com or Paragraphfour.com content, including but not limited to the obligations set forth in Section 6 of this Agreement, shall survive the termination or expiration of any subscription term.
b. This Agreement including Confirmation E-mail constitutes the entire agreement of the parties and supersedes any prior communication between the parties with respect to the subject matter hereof. Only a written instrument signed by both parties may amend it; electronic signatures are acceptable when agreed to by both parties. Without limitation of the foregoing, any purchase order or other instrument that the Subscriber may issue for Paragraphfour.com is for the Subscriber’s internal purposes only and will in no way modify, add to or subtract from the terms and conditions provided herein.
c. The Subscriber may not assign or transfer its rights under this Agreement unless to a successor organization.
d. This Agreement will be governed by the laws of the State of Florida. However, any action arising out of or relating to this Agreement or Paragraphfour.com may be brought in courts situated in Florida, and the parties consent to the jurisdiction of such courts.